- "I wish to provide God for those who seek His salvation, not spoon feed His word to those who already have their own."
- ―Father Timothy to the gathered Homestead residents.[src]
Timothy hailed from London, but traveled to America to spread the word of God. He eventually found his way to the Davenport Homestead, where the Assassin Ratonhnhaké:ton met him while he was resting at "The Mile's End", Oliver and Corrine's tavern.
There he explained his occupation as a parishioner, following which the fellow Homestead citizens exclaimed their want of a church in the area. Corrine mentioned that she and her husband, Oliver, had been missing their Sunday Mass; Ellen added that she wanted her daughter, Maria, to read the Bible more. In response, Connor gave Timothy the £1000 he needed to fund the construction of a church.
Connor was initially wary of Timothy, and only became close to him after Achilles' funeral, expressing interest in attending a church service. He later invited Timothy to play Fanorona with him at the Davenport Manor, just as he and his mentor used to.
He could also be seen standing outside his house a short distance away from the church, where he often met with other Homestead residents to read mail.